Warning – Spoilers. Still haven’t seen the first episode? View on CBS All Access (US), Space or CraveTV (Canada) or Netflix (worldwide excluding North America).
(Update: noon – including reactions from Alan Leightizer as an addendum)
Velvet Wells (Chief Engineer Tachyon Field) and Alan Leightizer (Lieutenant Guy Guyson) are crew of the USS Hummingbird. They have performed together at Holodeck Follies for the last five years.
Continue reading for their first reactions to Star Trek: Discovery “Vulcan Hello” (s1e1) — the first new Star Trek episode on network television in twelve years.
What is your first reaction to the show?
The “Vulcan Hello” is the first Star Trek episode that feels like a movie. This is an improvement over some Star Trek movies that felt like television episodes. It is superior to many other first episodes I’ve watched on Netflix. For example, this one episode is a palate cleanse from the entire first season of Marvel’s Iron Fist on Netflix.
What about the pre-credit scenes?
Starting with subtitled Klingons narrative was a bold move. Then women of colour, the Starfleet chevron and the ship through the clouds. Love the focus shifting toward Other perspectives rather than the humdrum boys-only tale telling.
What about the title screen?
The title screen was an interesting graphic throwback — it felt like a pulp Bond novel for space adventurers.
The theme song
The opening theme doesn’t have the heart of the Star Trek: DS9 theme but it is a welcome relief from the gaff that was Enterprise.
Which characters or moments stood out for you?
First… it is called Star Trek — space is gorgeous, the briar patch and binary star system is stunning.
Captain Georgiou and Cmdr Burnham have an interesting dynamic. Both strong minded but very different perspectives. The question of The Diplomat and The Soldier was very engaging Star Trek dialogue that I wish was further explored.
Saru is uninteresting so far, as a Marvin the Paranoid Robot/Eeyore type. He seems to have some computational abilities (biometrics especially) and is the Science Officer so he will likely have character growth around being more person than job.
Sarek might get better once Spock joins the academy but initially he looks like someone is interrupting his Matrix cosplay meetups. Actually, I’m just jealous I wasn’t invited.
What do you think of the ship?
The USS Shenzhou ship design is heavily JJ verse inspired. Like Federation idealism, it has a keen gloss to it. The transporter room looks older technology than the hallway and elevator.
From promotional material, the USS Discovery looks odd but so did the original Enterprise. (Team Voyager)
The holographic meetings are Star Wars inspired but they may offer some interaction dynamic that subspace screen conversations couldn’t muster.
What do you think of the Klingons?
The Klingon makeup is finally handled properly – alien looking with subtle skin tone and facial variations and, most importantly, no hint of blackface unlike other shows in the franchise.
Their ships are huge and intricate. Ancient and new tombs on the hull? Fearsome.
Any moment not work for you?
The Shenzhou crew doesn’t seem that remarkable but fortunately that won’t be an issue for long.
Since Burnham worked with Georgiou for seven years, it seems illogical that she would defy orders so drastically yet be considered Captain material. Also, she would know more effective means of convincing her Captain. However, it leads to prolonged tension between them and that’s okay too.
Are you looking forward to watching more episodes?
Yes! So far it is the right balance of treknobabble, moral angst and getting into trouble.
We already know that the Klingons will represent religious tyranny, war mongering and fascism in this franchise. We may not be able to defeat our enemy, but we can enjoy watching the Federation quell theirs.
Addendum from the logs of Lieutenant Guy Guyson (Alan Leightizer)
- So they can’t pick up two life forms on the planet but they can see a star shuffled into blowing sand? YAH RIGHT.
- Preflight checklist – nice to see actual procedure to starfleet, not just cowboying the shit out of stuff.
- Would the suit not be set to record data, including visual? We already have tiny cameras, why wouldn’t they be standard on Starfleet equipment like that.
- Burnham disobeyed a direct order.
- Why didn’t they send an automatic probe instead of their second in command? Program a flightpath there and back. The computer on the suit did all the flying anyway.
- 100 years since the Klingons were seen. With manufacturing being the way it is I’m not surprised fashion changes so quickly.
- The light of a “Star” three lightyears from the closest outpost would not have been noticed immediately by the Vulcans – that’s why they use subspace communications.
- Captain got over that vulcan neck pinch pretty quickly!
Maybe I missed something, but did they make the exact same mistake as Into Darkness in that they saved a species that was about to be destroyed by a natural disaster. A *natural* disaster. The Prime Directive isn’t “if they don’t see us, we’re ok.” Even if that was the case, not only were they seen walking away from the well, they probably also saw a massive vessel swoop down and beamed them away.
You’re missing the fact that Prime Directive is the General Order and therefore more lax. But, name a Federation Captain who doesn’t violate it every chance possible.
I am a little disappointed that the first one wasn’t done as a full on movie. If enables for better character development on which to base the series. There were a couple of space scenes that were poorly done in that I thought I was watching a cheep video game, but overall the effects were very well done. The costumes were great. I was hoping for the captain to feature strongly in future episodes, but who knows if she’ll turn up ‘not dead’ in a future episode. It was nice to finally see an Asian woman in a lead role, unless it really is her demise. The break down in the chain in command was poorly executed, and could have been better written as it didn’t fit with the character traits that they had just built up, in a feature film there would have been less time constraints for a director. With what happened between the captain and the second in command, it made the opening scene quite redundant.
Agreed with all points. Andie and Velvet were both disappointed that the relationship between Georgiou and Burnham was cut short. They were a very interesting pairing and it is sad to go back to humdrum white male captain mode. We also feel the first two episodes should have been put together as one longer episode – more movie like.